Superhuman alternative: CatchTheMail
Superhuman is a fast, keyboard-driven email client with a loyal user base, and its speed is genuine. This page is intended for those who value AI assistance with email but prefer not to change the application they use to read it.
Where Superhuman is strong
Superhuman replaces your email client. You sign in with your work account, and from then on you read, search and reply to everything within its interface, which is built around keyboard shortcuts and sub-second interactions. Its AI features are located in the same place: drafting, asking questions about your mail and automatic labelling.
If email is at the centre of your working day and you are prepared to change the tool you spend hours in, that commitment pays off. Muscle memory is the core benefit, and it can only be built by working consistently in one application.
Where CatchTheMail is different
CatchTheMail is not an email client and is not designed to become one. You continue to use Gmail, Outlook, Apple Mail or whichever client you already trust, with the same folders, the same signature and the same phone app. Your daily routine remains unchanged.
Instead, you receive a private forwarding address. When a message warrants careful attention, you forward it, and shortly afterwards you receive a complete analysis: how urgent it actually is, what it is really asking, and a reply written in a tone you can send as it stands.
The difference lies between coverage and commitment. Superhuman asks you to move your entire email workflow into a new application so that every message benefits. CatchTheMail requires nothing more than a single Forward, and assists only with the messages you select.
Cost, and who each price is intended for
Superhuman is priced per member: $25 per member per month on Starter and $33 on Business, both billed annually, with Enterprise handled by its sales team. It is a per-seat product designed for teams that want everyone working in the same client.
CatchTheMail starts at $16.99 per month for one person, and the plan you choose depends on how many messages you forward rather than how many people you employ. It is priced as a tool for the messages that matter, not as the environment in which you spend your entire day.
Neither pricing model is wrong. They answer different questions, and the most honest way to choose between them is to ask whether you genuinely want to change email clients.
Side by side
| Superhuman | CatchTheMail | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A replacement email client you sign into | A forwarding address; no client and no sign-in to your mail |
| Your existing app | You move into theirs | You continue using yours exactly as before |
| Access model | Connects to your email account | Sees only the messages you forward |
| Coverage | Everything, once you have moved | The messages you choose, one at a time |
| Price | $25 per member per month, or $33 on Business, billed annually | From $16.99 per month, per person |
| Free trial | See their site for current terms | 7 days, 50 analyses, no card |
Competitor details last verified on 12 August 2026, from Superhuman's own pricing page. Prices may change, so please check their current pricing before deciding.
When CatchTheMail is the wrong choice
Superhuman is a strong product, and there are clear cases in which it is the better choice. If the following apply to you, we recommend Superhuman.
- You want greater speed in reading email itself. We do not alter your reading experience in any way, so opening, searching and archiving do not become faster.
- You want AI applied to every message automatically. We see only what you forward, so messages that are not forwarded receive no assistance.
- You want your whole team standardised on one email client with shared admin and billing.
- You want keyboard shortcuts, split inboxes and instant search. These are email client features, and CatchTheMail is not an email client.
Other comparisons
Keep your inbox and add a second opinion
There is nothing to install and nothing to migrate. Forward one real message and assess whether the result is worth your time.
Start your 7-day free trial